For many of us, working from home during COVID-19 has meant we are spending a lot of time on video meeting applications like Zoom. The effects of this have taken us by surprise.
Having giant heads staring at us up close for long periods can be off-putting for a lot of us. Never mind that we feel we should fix our hair (COVID mullet anyone?), put on makeup, or get out of our pajamas.
So why are online meetings more tiring than face-to-face ones?
People feel like they have to make more emotional effort to appear interested, and in the absence of many non-verbal cues, the intense focus on words and sustained eye contact is exhausting.
Meetings in person are not only about the exchange of knowledge; they are also important rituals in the office. Rituals provide comfort, put us at ease, and are essential in building and maintaining rapport.
Face-to-face meetings are also important mechanisms for the communication of attitudes and feelings among business partners and colleagues. Emotions precede and follow all our behaviors, and influence management decision-making. Sensitive topics are often canvassed, requiring us to notice subtleties and display empathy.
How are Zoom meetings different from in-person meetings?
Our brains can only do so many things consciously at once, because we have limited working memory. In contrast, we can process much more information unconsciously, as we do with body language.
Meeting online increases our cognitive load, because several of its features take up a lot of conscious capacity.
1. We miss out on a lot of non-verbal communication
Our feelings and attitudes are largely conveyed by nonverbal signals such as facial expressions, the tone and pitch of the voice, gestures, posture and the distance between the communicators. In a face-to-face meeting, we process these cues largely automatically and we can still listen to the speaker at the same time. But on a video chat, we need to work harder to process nonverbal cues. Paying more attention to these consumes a lot of energy.
Also, in face-to-face meetings we rely heavily on nonverbal cues to make emotional judgements, such as assessing whether a statement is credible. We automatically take in information such as: Is the person fidgeting? Relying predominantly on verbal information to infer other people’s emotions is tiring for us.
2. What if the kids run in?
We feel anxious about our remote workspace and events that might make us look bad to our colleagues. Will my Zoom background suddenly fail, leaving my hoarding tendencies on full display?
And none of us want to be like Trinny Woodall, fashion guru and television presenter, who was doing a livestream when her partner walked naked across the room.
I was watching (a couple of weeks ago) Trinny Woodall doing a live presentation from her bathroom on Facebook and Charles Saatchi suddenly appeared naked!! Put me off my porridge…🧐🙄😳😯🥣
— ANNE (@annethompson7) May 2, 2020
3. No water-cooler catch-ups
In person, we often meet people on the way to a meeting to catch up on issues or discuss our views before going in. We get coffee, and the simple act of relocating to a different room is energizing. But at home, we might be just working on a task and then we get on to Zoom, often without taking breaks.
Also, walking is known to improve creativity, highlighting the importance of discussions while walking to meetings, moving around during the meeting, and holding the now popular stand-up meetings. But we can’t walk on Zoom calls.
And where we meet matters. The physical environment acts as a cognitive scaffold — we attribute certain meanings to meeting rooms — and this subtly changes our behavior. This can include anchors to important topics such as creativity and problem solving.
4. Looking at our own face is stressful
The heightened emphasis on facial cues and the ability to see oneself can also act as a stressor. Viewing our own negative facial expressions, like anger and disgust, can lead to more intense emotions than when viewing similar facial expressions in others.
5. Are you listening or are you frozen?
Silence in real-life conversation is important and creates a natural rhythm. But in a video call, silence can make you anxious. Even a 1.2 second delay in responding online made people perceive the person talking as less friendly or focused.
In addition, frustration with people turning their microphones on and off, lagging connections, and background noise mean the meeting rarely flows as smoothly.
But it’s not all Zoom and doom
On the upside, social anxiety is positively correlated with feelings of comfort online. So for people who dread physical meetings, meeting online might be a welcome respite.
And even though the increased focus on verbal information in video meetings can be mentally more draining, it might also have some potential positive side effects by reducing biases due to social and emotional signals. For instance, certain physical factors, such as height, are linked to social dominance.
But these factors are less apparent in video meetings, which could lead to increased emphasis on the merits of arguments.
How can we reduce the fatigue?
With predictions that the new workplace “normal” will be very different from the old one, it seems that Zoom is here to stay. However, there are a number of steps we can take to reduce the negative effects of online video meetings.
Firstly, consider whether the meeting needs to happen. In some cases, shared document platforms with detailed comments can reduce the need to meet.
Limiting the number of Zoom meetings in a day can assist, as well as using messaging and email.
And sometimes, the phone is better. On the phone, we only have to concentrate on one voice and can walk around which can help thinking.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
Watch Libby Sander‘s TEDxStHildasSchool Talk here: